Listen to this article:
0:00
0:00

Alabama’s CHOOSE Act is growing fast. The program awarded $100 million in Education Savings Accounts (ESAs) to 19,000 students in 2025–26, and an estimated $174 million to 34,000 students in 2026–27. Each award works like a scholarship: up to $7,000 per student for approved school expenses, or up to $2,000 per student ($4,000 per family) for home education. 

Bigger growth is coming. Starting in 2027–28, the income cap of 300% of the federal poverty level goes away, and the only limit will be the money set aside. The FY2027 budget sets aside $236 million, about 2% of state K–12 spending. That raises a fair question: does the CHOOSE Act take money from Alabama’s public schools? 

Where the money comes from 

The state supplies about 63% of public school funding, with local and federal sources adding 19% each. State dollars flow through the Education Trust Fund (ETF), built mainly on income and sales taxes earmarked for education. 

The CHOOSE Act draws on that same tax base. ESAs are paid from a separate CHOOSE Act Fund, filled by designated income tax revenue and by ETF appropriations. Because that revenue is earmarked, every CHOOSE Act dollar is one that could otherwise have gone to K–12 schools or colleges. 

How Alabama’s state tax revenue funds both public schools and the CHOOSE Act. Sources: Alabama Executive Budget Office; Alabama Legislative Services Agency; Ala. Code § 16-6J-8.

What other states show

Florida and Arizona have no income caps, and their programs now equal roughly 10% of K–12 public spending: $4.3 billion in Florida and $1.2 billion in Arizona. Arizona’s ESA spending jumped about 211% in a single year after it opened eligibility to all families in 2022.

In both states, school choice spending climbed sharply after universal eligibility took effect. Sources: NCES and EdChoice, 2026 Spending Share Rankings.

What it means for local schools

The effect on any one school system is less direct than many assume. As of September 30, 2026, only 14% of approved students had attended public school before applying. About 61% of activated ESAs went to private schools and 38% to home education.

The state funding formula also isn’t one-for-one. A student who leaves doesn’t cost a district $7,000, and a few departures won’t change its staffing allocation. Larger losses will, though, and costs like buses, buildings, and utilities don’t shrink with enrollment. Small and rural systems may find it hardest to adjust.

The bottom line

ESA awards aren’t subtracted from any local school budget, and today the program is about 2% of the $10.5 billion education budget. But as eligibility opens to every family, the CHOOSE Act will place growing demands on the same state dollars that fund public schools and colleges. Better data on enrollment, funding, and operating costs, especially in small and rural systems, will be key to tracking its impact.

Read the full policy brief, “The CHOOSE Act and Public-School Funding: Separating Fact from Fiction,” for complete data and sources.